Why It Matters:

Credentials of value can give learners an advantage in both postsecondary education and the labor market. The strongest demonstrate mastery of technical skills, signal readiness to employers, and stack toward further education, reducing the time and cost of future training. But that value isn’t automatic. Most credentials don’t deliver it, so districts must choose carefully.

Credentials of value serve two domains of thriving most directly: knowledge and capability, through demonstrated skills that build toward further learning, and economic security and mobility, through better odds of a good job. But the number of credentials earned says little about whether learners are better off. The real test is what each credential leads to.

More than 1.8 million unique credentials are currently offered by more than 134,000 providers in the United States alone, and total annual expenditure across institutions, employers, governments, and the military exceeds $2.34 trillion (via Credential Engine, 2025). In this crowded landscape, credentials aligned with high-demand fields are far more likely to lead to better wages or further education. Some credentials lead to strong wages on their own, but the strongest pathways let learners earn them while progressing toward a degree. Counting Credentials 2025 identifies seven credential categories, each serving distinct purposes in learning and skills development: badges, certificates, micro-credentials, certifications, degrees, licenses, and secondary school credentials. At last count, badges (1,022,028), certificates (486,352), and degrees (264,099) make up the largest share.

However, not all credentials carry equal weight. Of roughly 23,000 credentials studied by the Burning Glass Institute, just 12 percent, about 1 in 8, led to significant wage gains. A 2020 analysis of credential data from 30 states, conducted by ExcelinEd and The Burning Glass Technologies, found that fewer than 20 percent of credentials earned by high school students aligned with employer-in-demand credentials. Of the ten most frequently earned credentials, only three appeared among the top ten most in-demand. Many of the commonly earned credentials had little relevance to actual workforce needs.

Credentials tend to work best alongside further education, not in place of it. A 2024 Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas analysis found that 61 percent of job postings requiring an associate degree also sought a certification, compared with 22 percent of postings requiring a high school diploma. Georgetown University’s Center on Education and the Workforce projects that 66 percent of good jobs in 2031 will be on the bachelor’s degree pathway. Just 19 percent will be on the “middle-skills pathway,” which includes associate degrees and certificates, barely more than the 15 percent available to those with only a high school diploma. Yet fewer than a third (31.6%) of students who started at a community college in fall 2018 transferred to a four-year institution within six years, and fewer than half of those (48.7%) went on to earn a bachelor’s degree.

Districts should only offer credentials that are rigorous, aligned with real labor market demand, and worth learners’ time and money. Rewarding credentials earned for their own sake, regardless of what they lead to, works against learners’ goals. Districts should also watch for sorting. When some learners are steered toward credentials while their peers are prepared for degrees, pathways risk reproducing the tracking systems they were meant to disrupt. Students who attend low-poverty high schools are about twice as likely as those in high-poverty schools to enroll in a bachelor’s degree program right after high school. For two-year enrollment, the pattern reverses.

Go deeper: All4Ed’s “Hall of Mirrors” examines what the evidence shows about credentials, degrees, and the risk of sorting young people into inequitable tracks.

These strategies describe how districts can build a set of credential offerings that delivers real value for learners. Together, they help districts choose, validate, and regularly review credentials that lead to real opportunities in college and careers.

  • Establish a framework to classify credentials based on demand, wage value, and whether they stack toward further education, ensuring alignment with emerging industry needs.
  • Require evidence of employer demand and learner outcomes from credential providers before adopting a new credential.
  • Validate credentials with employers, workforce boards, and postsecondary institutions, using shared rubrics or tools to reassess their value in the regional labor market on a set cycle.
  • Audit current credential offerings regularly, and retire low-value, non-transferable credentials to guard against “credential clutter.”
  • Prioritize credentials that have portability across state lines and employer sectors to ensure long-term value.
  • Be cautious about credentials tied to narrow tasks that may change quickly as AI reshapes work. Favor credentials that build broad, transferable capability and stack toward further learning.
  • Align credential offerings with postsecondary pathways and pair them with dual enrollment and other college-credit opportunities, so learners earn them alongside progress toward a degree, not in place of one.
  • Embed credential preparation and attainment into course sequences, aligning curriculum and assessments to certification standards, rather than offering credentials as stand-alone options.
  • Pair credential programs with work-based learning and employer connections, so learners leave with relationships, not just a certificate.
  • Let learners choose credentials that fit their own goals, and offer credentials across multiple fields so a credential doesn’t lock a learner into one career before they’re ready.
  • Ensure advising helps learners and families understand what each credential leads to: the jobs, wages, and further education it connects to.
  • Provide access and support to all learners, including those outside traditional CTE programs, and fund exam fees, equipment, and other costs so cost is never the barrier.
  • Monitor credential attainment and post-graduation outcomes, disaggregated by learner group, to center equity and inform continuous improvement.
  • Review whether credential pathways are steering some learner groups away from degree-aligned coursework, and address any patterns of tracking.
  • Measure value, not volume. Report the share of credentials earned that meet the district’s criteria for value, not simply the total number earned.
  • Launch digital portfolios so learners can showcase credentials in resumes, applications, and online profiles.
  • Publicly celebrate the attainment of credentials of value, recognizing learners at school events, board meetings, and community showcases.

Use these questions with your leadership team, counselors, employers, and workforce partners to examine whether the credentials you offer lead somewhere worthwhile. They are designed to surface which credentials deliver real value for learners, which should be reconsidered, and which learners have access to them.

  • Are learners choosing credentials that fit their own goals, or earning whatever credential their program offers?
  • If a learner’s interests change partway through, what happens to the time and progress they’ve invested in a credential?
  • Are the credentials we offer aligned with state-approved high-value lists, real job opportunities, and postsecondary enrollment in our region? How do we know? What data are we using?
  • Which credentials offered in our district are valued by both colleges and employers and lead to high-wage, high-demand opportunities? Which credentials don’t and should be reevaluated?
  • Do the credentials we offer stack toward further education, or do any of them lead to dead ends?
  • What evidence of employer demand and learner outcomes do we require before adopting a new credential? How often do we reassess the ones we already offer, and what would cause us to retire one?
  • How are we judging whether the credentials we offer will hold their value as AI changes the skills employers need?
  • How are credentials embedded into pathways, rather than offered as stand-alone experiences?
  • How are credentials recognized for postsecondary credit or advanced standing at partner institutions?
  • Are learners earning credentials alongside college credit, or in place of it?
  • Do learners and families understand what each credential leads to before they commit time to it?
  • What supports (financial, academic, advising) are provided to ensure learners complete credential requirements successfully?
  • Which learner groups are underrepresented in earning credentials, and what strategies are in place to close participation and attainment gaps?
  • Are some learner groups more likely to be steered toward credentials while others are steered toward degree pathways?
  • How do we track credential attainment, and how is that data used for continuous improvement and equity monitoring?
  • What share of the credentials our learners earn meet our criteria for value? Do we report and celebrate that share, or the total count?
  • In what ways are employers, workforce boards, higher ed partners, and local and state agencies helping us co-design, validate, fund, and monitor our credential offerings?

These practices show what a strong credentials of value strategy can look like in action. Districts can adapt them to their own context and regional labor market, starting with the practices that address their most pressing gaps.

  • Credentials offered are stackable, portable, and backed by evidence of employer demand and wage outcomes in the state and region.
  • Credential offerings are audited regularly, and those without evidence of employer demand or wage gains are retired.
  • Employer and workforce board partners validate credential value on a set cycle, keeping offerings aligned to demand.
  • Credentials of value are offered across multiple sectors, giving learners options without adding low-value credentials to fill gaps.
  • Credentials are embedded in academic and CTE pathways alongside dual enrollment, so learners earn them with progress toward a degree, not in place of one.
  • Credential-to-credit crosswalks, mapped with higher education partners, give learners advanced standing toward their degrees.
  • Credential preparation is integrated into coursework, making it part of the learning process rather than an add-on.
  • Credential programs are paired with work-based learning, so learners build relationships with employers while earning the credential.
  • Exam fees, equipment, and certification costs are covered, so cost is never a barrier.
  • Credential advising is built into education and career navigation, so learners and families know what each credential leads to.
  • Credentials appear in learner portfolios, where colleges and employers can see them.
  • Credential attainment and post-graduation outcomes are tracked by learner group, and districts report the share of credentials earned that meet their criteria for value.
  • Annual equity reviews compare which learner groups earn credentials alone and which earn them alongside college credit.
  • Graduate follow-up surveys ask whether credentials helped learners get a good job or continue their education.
  • Districts publicly celebrate the attainment of valuable credentials to reinforce learner achievement and expand community awareness.

Chosen carefully, credentials of value give learners an advantage as they step into their futures by providing evidence of skills that matter in both college and the workforce. When districts prioritize Credentials of Value and remove barriers to access, they ensure learners graduate with diplomas and credentials that stack toward further education, open doors to good jobs, and support their path to thriving in learning, work, and life. When Education and Career Navigation, Dual Enrollment, Work-Based Learning, and Credentials of Value work together, Future Ready Pathways create coherent, learner-centered systems that expand opportunity, help close equity gaps, and prepare each learner with clear, actionable next steps for success, regardless of the path forward they choose.

Credential Validation Planning Tool

With well over a million credentials in the U.S. labor market, not all lead to opportunity. This tool helps education leaders and their partners evaluate which credentials are worth offering. It includes questions around value, transferability, stackability, alignment with high-wage careers, and equitable access, ensuring that credentialing pathways are future ready and serve all students well.

  • San Antonio Independent School District

    Texas

  • Harlingen Consolidated Independent School District

    Texas

  • Minnetonka Public Schools

    Minnesota

Looking Ahead: Profiles in Practice

Looking Ahead: Profiles in Practice

Profiles in Practice show these strategies at work in districts and schools across the country, and how Future Ready Pathways can be adapted to local contexts, scaled with intention, and sustained over time. Each story offers practical ideas for leaders ready to take the next step.